Faces - A Nod Is as Good as a Wink…to a Blind Horse
Release Date: March 1971
Date I Got: 26 March 2005
Best Track: Debris
Other Notable Tracks: Stay With Me, Miss Judy’s Farm, That’s All You Need, Memphis
Historicity, I believe, is a key component in determining "good" music. This makes new music reviews exercises in prognostication, guesses at the direction of popular and not-so-popular trends. It’s much easy to write and think and deal with a thirty-six year old album than a six month old one. Writing and thinking and approaching, say, The Beatles or The Eagles, carries a certain amount of baggage, but you know where they stand in history. So, you don’t like the Beatles, but it hardly changes the fact that they’re the predicate for a whole bunch of modern music.
Historicity cuts both ways. Time has that habit if cutting and discarding the chaff as being unimportant or unnecessary. Today’s second-tier band is still worth listening to, but will that be true for my kids? Is a second-tier band from my parents’ generation worth spending time with? Not all that is cut away is bad, but not every hidden gem shines.
I am assuming Faces–and early Rod Stewart in general–to be second-tier, but that doesn’t mean it isn’t fuckin’ amazing, because it is. My point is this: age doesn’t make a whole lot of things better and music isn’t one of them.
But whatever. If I’d been around with this came out, it’d probably be counted among my favorites. Even so, I do have friends that count it as such. I find it hard to really get into this album despite how great it is. I think age has a lot to do with it. It’s an album that has, if you will, potential contextual energy while a lot of newer music (and the great old stuff) has more of a kinetic contextual energy. What I mean is: no one cites Faces or Rod Stewart as influence. Maybe this is sad–I’m willing to hear arguments–but it doesn’t worry me all that much.
This is the only Faces/Rod Stewart I have, which probably is sad. If you’re looking to get into it, this is a great start, as every track is excellent. The production isn’t great, but that’s a personal issue I have with a lot of late 60’s/early 70’s rock albums.
Still, I’m not going to crank this in order to enlighten the neighbors as I do some other music.
Addition: You really have to love youtube. Watch both of these live versions, then tell me I’m wrong about all the above, because I am. Right now I’m adding "Seeing a Faces Show" to the list of things I’m going to do when I build a time machine. Were the 70’s really this fun?
Get a Second Opinion!![allmusic]
[Live - Stay With Me] [Live - Miss Judy’s Farm] [Live - Memphis]
